Russia’s Population Collapse is Worse Than We Thought

Paul J. Warburg 25 min

Vladimir Putin has a use-them-while-you've-got-them mentality. Once the war in Ukraine is over, it's going to seem like small cookies compared to what happens to Russia over the ensuing decades and generations.

  • Vladimir Putin
  • Alexei Navalny

Chapters

  1. 0:00

    Russia's demographic collapse accelerates due to war

    There are now more Russian men dying on a monthly basis just in Russia's war against Ukraine than there are new Russian boys being born into the country. This situation is worsening as casualty rates increase while birth rates continue to fall, with total monthly births dropping to around 90,000. Without the war, this low birth rate would already be a crisis, but combined with potential casualties nearing 50,000 men per month, Russia is sacrificing its next generation.

  2. 4:35

    Historical context and the scale of casualties

    Russia has now reached the milestone of 1.6 million casualties in their war against Ukraine, equivalent to wiping out entire cities like Phoenix or Philadelphia. This loss is heavily skewed toward men, creating a situation similar to China's demographic crisis from its one-child policy but with opposite gender imbalances. The crisis stems from World War II losses which created a generational gap still affecting Russian society today.

  3. 10:17

    Three drivers of population decline

    Russia has three major drivers that are absolutely eviscerating their population: a low birth rate, a high death rate, and really poor performance when it comes to net migration. The fertility rate is only 1.35 births per Russian woman, far below the replacement level of 2.1, while life expectancy for men is roughly 68 years due to alcoholism and other issues. More people are leaving Russia than entering, including educated citizens with passports who do not wish to return.

  4. 19:07

    The vulnerability of eastern territories

    Russia has been emptying out entire small Russian cities, particularly those east of the Ural Mountains, by recruiting men from there to fight in the war. These small villages and sparse areas are losing the men necessary to maintain infrastructure and roads, effectively making them uncontrolled territory. Without a population to possess the land, Russia may lose direct physical control over these sensitive border regions.

  5. 21:06

    China's potential expansion and nuclear deterrence

    There's really nothing to stop China at this point if they decided to invade Russia's eastern territories because they are now empty of men. While Russia threatens nuclear retaliation, these threats have never been weaker due to a lack of follow-through on previous red lines. This creates a scenario where China might feel emboldened to expand while Russia remains vulnerable.

  6. 23:19

    Putin's strategic gamble and legacy

    Vladimir Putin has a use-them-while-you've-got-them mentality, wanting a legacy of growing Russia on the map even at the expense of his people. This strategy prioritizes territorial size over the well-being of the population, leading to a demographic catastrophe that will define Russia for generations. The consequences of this gamble will be far more severe than the war itself once it ends.

Key points

  • 0:00

    There are now more Russian men dying on a monthly basis just in Russia's war against Ukraine than there are new Russian boys being born into the country.

  • 0:00

    Using the most recently available data, there are only about 90,000 total monthly live births in all of Russia.

  • 4:35

    Russia has now reached the milestone of 1.6 million casualties in their war against Ukraine.

  • 9:38

    The current fertility rate in Russia is about 1.35 births per Russian woman.

  • 11:34

    They have a life expectancy that's about 10 years younger than the average Russian woman at about 68 years.

  • 12:41

    Russia has net negative migration, meaning more people are moving out of the society than there are moving into the society.

  • 17:42

    Russia has been emptying out entire small Russian cities east of the Ural Mountains by recruiting men from those regions.

  • 20:09

    There's really nothing to stop China at this point if they decided to invade Russia's eastern territories.

  • 20:09

    Russia is now sitting on a track record of dozens and dozens and dozens, probably over 100 nuclear threats that they've made since they started the war against Ukraine that they haven't followed through on.

  • 22:40

    Vladimir Putin wants to pursue that even at the expense of his people, because the elites just fawn over these big, big maps.

  • 23:54

    Russia is going to live with the results of this war and their demographic problem in general forever.

On the map

Map of the places in “Russia’s Population Collapse is Worse Than We Thought”

Who and where

Places · 9

  • Russia 96
  • Ukraine 17
  • People's Republic of China 11
  • United States 4
  • Phoenix 2
  • Philadelphia 2
  • Ural Mountains 2
  • Central Asia 1
  • Soviet Union 1

People · 2

  • Drawing of Vladimir Putin

    Vladimir Putin 14

    President of the Russian Federation

    Photo 1

  • Drawing of Alexei Navalny

    Alexei Navalny 2

    Russian jurist and opposition leader (1976–2024)

    Photo 2

1. Photo: Пресс-служба Президента России, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Wikidata · redrawn in our house style (Vladimir Putin)

2. Photo: Navalny's Team, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Wikidata · redrawn in our house style (Alexei Navalny)

Organisations · 6

  • full-scale Russo-Ukrainian war 16
  • Russians 2
  • World War II 3
  • Western world 2
  • Great Patriotic War 1
  • Homestead Acts 1
Map of the places in “Russian Soldiers are Suddenly Being Wiped Out Like Never Before” 25:25

Russian Soldiers are Suddenly Being Wiped Out Like Never Before

Paul J. Warburg

Russia is experiencing a catastrophic decline where casualty rates exceed recruitment and birth rates, leading to societal collapse. The war has eliminated any hope for Russia's demographic recovery and is running its society into the ground.

Map of the places in “Russia Is Struggling to Defend Its Own Capital” 7:30

Russia Is Struggling to Defend Its Own Capital

Peter Zeihan

The combination of fuel shortages and the risks of peripheral mobilization makes the current situation looking pretty bad for the Kremlin. The convergence of battlefield losses and social pressure from forced mobilization creates a dangerous situation for the Kremlin.

25:12

Russia's New Recruitment Crisis is Next Level Incompetence

Paul J. Warburg

Russia cannot fix its core problems because it lacks willing technical experts and relies on desperate tactics that fail against an innovative Ukrainian society. Ukraine will be victorious because its innovative capabilities and defensive preparations overwhelm Russia's desperate mobilization efforts.

39:38

The Ukraine War is About to Get MUCH Worse for Russia

Paul J. Warburg

The war is becoming more of a disaster for Russia every single day. There's a reason that President Zelensky, just a couple days before I recorded this video, sent a letter to Vladimir Putin taunting him, essentially saying exactly that, saying that Ukraine is ready for peace talks whenever Russia is.

38:01

Russia is Running Out of Russians

Paul J. Warburg

Russia has essentially already ceased to be a relevant global power, because their demographic crisis has now reached the point of no return. Because they focused so much on old world imperial ideology, their empire will crumble.

AI-generated summary · model qwen3.5:9b-12k · prompt version whole-5.window-7.combine-10.s-f4be8e · video id q8fuhio_frI · Watch on YouTube