A Break for Ukraine

Peter Zeihan 9 min

The potential provision of precision targeting information could destroy Russia's primary income source and force allies to stop subsidizing the war. Once the intel is provided, for every day that it is there, the Ukrainians will definitely be striking, leading to a dramatic change in the course of the war.

  • Donald Trump
  • Vladimir Putin
  • Tulsi Gabbard
  • Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Chapters

  1. 0:00

    Trump Administration's New Stance on Ukraine

    The Trump administration is considering providing precision targeting information for Russia's energy system. US administrations have historically avoided actions that drive up global energy prices.

  2. 0:30

    Impact of Shale Revolution on Policy

    The US transition from largest oil importer to exporter has loosened previous energy price constraints. The Biden administration halted Ukrainian attacks on Russian energy assets due to fears of global price spikes. Early in his campaign, Trump displayed hostility toward the Ukrainian government.

  3. 2:35

    Trump's Misunderstanding of Russian Motivations

    Trump incorrectly believes the war was caused by Biden's presidency rather than long-standing geopolitical issues. Trump has removed experienced advisors and installed Tulsi Gabbard to filter out negative information about Russia.

  4. 5:03

    Role of Steve Witkoff in Negotiations

    Steve Witkoff, lacking foreign policy experience, was entrusted with negotiations and failed to counter Russian propaganda. After a brief summit where Putin dominated, Trump realized he had been played and is reconsidering policy.

  5. 6:34

    Ukrainian Resumption of Energy Attacks

    Ukraine has resumed targeting Russian refineries, potentially reducing capacity by 40%. Destroying Russian oil exports could force allies like Iran and China to stop subsidizing the war.

  6. 8:21

    Uncertainty of Future Policy Direction

    The outcome depends entirely on Trump, who has changed his mind frequently since January.

Key points

  • 0:00

    Donald Trump personally says that fairly soon the United States is going to be providing the Ukrainians with precision targeting information for the Russian energy system deep within the Russian Federation itself.

  • 0:00

    The U.S. administration, not just this one, all of them going back at least until the 70s have always been a little paranoid about energy prices.

  • 0:30

    That relationship has loosened quite a bit in the last 20 years, largely because of the Shale Revolution in the United States, which has taken the United States from the world's largest oil importer to the world's largest oil exporter.

  • 0:30

    Well, the Biden administration shut that down because they were afraid of the impact that it was going to have on global energy prices.

  • 0:30

    The Trump administration has been very erratic. In the early days, they were pathologically hostile to the Ukrainian government, up to and including inviting Zelensky to the White House just so they could yell at him.

  • 2:35

    And the only people think that the Russians invaded because Biden was president are Trump, the people around him, and some mega hardcore folks.

  • 2:35

    He has gutted the top of the National Security and Foreign Policy staff... He's not using the State Department. He's not using the National Security Council.

  • 5:03

    So Witkoff has no foreign policy experience, and Trump basically entrusted him with the entire portfolio for all negotiations all over the world.

  • 5:03

    And we started to get Trump looking at other bits of information... And he started to realize that he had been played the fool and that he was acting like a fool.

  • 6:34

    The Ukrainians have started targeting Russian energy infrastructure again... And that number is now up to 40%.

  • 6:34

    And then countries like Iran and China, which have been taking money from Russia and sending them drones and drone parts, will have to decide whether they want to directly subsidize the Russian government's war in Ukraine.

  • 8:21

    Will this happen? That's entirely up to Donald Trump. He has changed his mind by my math 77 times since January 20th.

Who and where

People · 4

  • Drawing of Donald Trump

    Donald Trump 15

    President of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)

    Photo 1

  • Drawing of Vladimir Putin

    Vladimir Putin 5

    President of the Russian Federation

    Photo 2

  • Drawing of Tulsi Gabbard

    Tulsi Gabbard 2

    American politician (born 1981)

    Photo 3

  • Drawing of Volodymyr Zelenskyy

    Volodymyr Zelenskyy 1

    President of Ukraine since 2019

    Photo 4

1. Photo: Daniel Torok, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons · Wikidata · redrawn in our house style (Donald Trump)

2. Photo: Пресс-служба Президента России, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Wikidata · redrawn in our house style (Vladimir Putin)

3. Photo: Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons · Wikidata · redrawn in our house style (Tulsi Gabbard)

4. Photo: Press Service of the President of Ukraine, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Wikidata · redrawn in our house style (Volodymyr Zelenskyy)

8:05

Why Trump's Stance on Ukraine Has Changed - Part 2

Peter Zeihan

Russia views this war as its last chance to survive and has more nukes than the US, making it dangerous to leave them unchecked. Trump is now directing policy against Putin after realizing he was being lied to, though the specific outcome remains uncertain.

8:24

What Happens After Trump and Putin Split?

Peter Zeihan

Donald Trump must either dedicate his entire presidency to the Ukraine issue or rebuild a competent government staff to avoid disastrous national security decisions. The current administration's lack of competent staff and reliance on uninformed advisors prevents effective policy implementation.

+1
7:45

The U.S. Helps India and Russia Helps Iran

Peter Zeihan

The Trump administration granted India temporary waivers to import Russian crude after Persian Gulf supplies were cut off. Meaningful policy change will not occur until pro-Russian advisors like Witkoff and Gabbard are removed.

10:25

Trump and Putin Split, Ukraine Gets Aid Again

Peter Zeihan

Trump's potential overreaction could trigger erratic military and economic policies that cause long-term problems. These actions will fall under the category of things that you wish for don't always go the way that you were hoping.

8:18

Trump's 28-Point Peace Plan to End the Ukraine War

Peter Zeihan

The plan forces Ukraine to never apply for NATO membership and enshrine that refusal into their constitution. I consider that a win.

AI-generated summary · model qwen3.5:9b-12k · prompt version whole-3.window-7.combine-10.s-f4be8e · video id rCtfhE4LqXg · Watch on YouTube