Can the British Reopen the Strait of Hormuz?
Peter Zeihan
6 min
There is not a military solution to this problem because no other country has enough naval force. The best scenario is that the US pulls out completely and the Iranians just move on, which is not likely.
-
Donald Trump
Chapters
-
0:00
The British Coalition Attempt
Peter Zeihan discusses the news of Britain attempting to build a coalition without the US to force open the Strait of Hormuz.
-
0:31
The Post-WWII Security System
Zeihan explains how the US allowed allies to trade globally in exchange for writing their security policies, leading to a lack of independent navies.
-
1:33
The Reality of Current Naval Power
Zeihan states that only five navies are worthy of the name, but only three can reach the Persian Gulf from home. Zeihan describes how Iran has established a toll system where ships must check in and pay money to pass through their sector. Zeihan notes that Iranian drones have a range of at least a couple hundred miles, making simple escort impossible without occupying the coastline. Zeihan compares the Iranian coastline length to the US coast from New York City down to Savannah, highlighting the massive scale required for occupation.
-
4:01
The Necessity of a Political Deal
Zeihan concludes that since no other country has meaningful amphibious capacity, the only solution is a political deal with Iran. Zeihan states that every defense official warned presidents since 1979 about the consequences of war, but the Trump administration chose to ignore them. Zeihan suggests the best scenario is the US pulling out completely and hoping Iranians just move on, which he believes is not likely.
Key points
- 0:00
The news involves the Brits attempting to build a coalition without the United States.
- 0:31
Most countries gave up having navies in exchange for US security policies after World War II.
- 1:33
There are only five navies in the world worthy of the name.
- 1:33
Only three countries have meaningful naval progression capability to reach the Persian Gulf from home.
- 1:33
The French might be able to reach the Gulf but only if they can use Suez.
- 1:33
Combined firepower of all other nations is less than what the US already has on station.
- 1:33
Iranian drones have a range of at least a couple hundred miles.
- 1:33
The Iranian coastline is as long as the US coast from New York City down to Savannah.
- 4:01
There are not enough countries with meaningful amphibious capacity to secure the coastline.
- 4:01
The only option to remove the threat to shipping is a political deal with Iran.
Who and where
People · 1
-
Donald Trump 4
President of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
Photo 1
1. Photo: Daniel Torok, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons · Wikidata · redrawn in our house style (Donald Trump)
Related episodes
This Ain't Your Father's Tanker War
Peter Zeihan
The U.S. Navy no longer has the ability to impose a strategic reality on the local basis against a fourth-rate security power. It is very, very difficult to restore access to waterways during future conflicts.
The Iran War: Enter Sting Interceptors
Peter Zeihan
Preserving global infrastructure now runs through Kiev, as Gulf states realize the need for Ukrainian tech. The best chance for preserving infrastructure runs through Kiev, and Gulf states will likely invest immense cash there.
Why Nobody Came to Help the U.S in Iran
Peter Zeihan
Allies did not help because they lack independent naval power and were excluded from intelligence sharing. The situation is a trap caused by a leader who refuses to surround himself with anyone but sycophants.
The Blockade of Iran Begins
Peter Zeihan
To pressure the IRGC effectively, the US must block oil exports and prevent drone imports. The blockade is the first action that successfully targets the IRGC's specific financial interests.
U.S. Ground Troops Coming to Iran
Peter Zeihan
Occupying Karg Island is a bad idea because it removes Iran's oil income and invites devastating retaliation. The current plan to occupy Karg Island will end in a bit of a debacle.
AI-generated summary · model qwen3.5:9b-12k · prompt version whole-3.window-7.combine-10.s-f4be8e ·
video id 3PPJWjZhLxw ·
Watch on YouTube